Dueling MLB mock draft: Constructing 2024 prospect superteams

The 2024 MLB draft is simply over every week away, so we requested three of our MLB specialists to strive their hand at choosing a primary spherical consisting of this 12 months’s prime prospects.

The principles of our superteam draft are easy: Jeff Passan, Jesse Rogers and David Schoenfield snake-drafted by way of 10 rounds (30 complete picks) to place collectively the absolute best roster of 2024 prospects.

Every roster consists of a full lineup: two pitchers, catcher, first baseman, second baseman, third baseman, shortstop and three outfielders. The drafters have been allowed to decide on positions in any order and their methods present which spots are deepest — or most shallow — on this 12 months’s class. After the picks have been made — with a wholesome dose of trash discuss blended in — ESPN MLB draft analyst Kiley McDaniel broke down all three groups and declared a champion.

Let the dueling mock draft start!

---

High draft prospects | Watch: July 14 at 7 p.m. ET on ESPN

1. Charlie Condon, 3B, Georgia (Schoenfield)

2. Travis Bazzana, CF/2B, Oregon State (Passan)

3. Jac Caglianone, 1B, Florida (Rogers)

Schoenfield: Let’s not overthink this. Condon simply had one of many biggest seasons in NCAA historical past, one thing out of the juiced-bat period of the Eighties. His numbers tower over what Wyatt Langford and Dylan Crews did a 12 months in the past within the SEC. In different phrases: I’ve already gained this draft.

Passan: Congratulations, Dave. You bought a man with (checks notes) a decrease on-base share than mine. And (checks different notes) a worse strikeout-to-walk ratio. And who (checks extra notes) will find yourself at a place with far decrease defensive worth. Condon is nice. Simply remember that Bazzana is, too. And that there are many picks left so that you can screw up.

Rogers: Dave, you are patting your self on the again for taking the Golden Spikes winner? OK. Nicely, I simply received a 2-for-1 in Caglianone who would possibly or may not pitch whereas mashing dwelling runs — however I like the chances. He is a cornerstone participant.

McDaniel: I’ve Condon and Bazzana as a digital coin flip on the prime, so Passan will get a pleasant worth at No. 2. It isn’t a straightforward name on who to take at three — my rankings lock subsequent week and I am nonetheless mulling it over — however Cags will not be it for me and his place is possibly the best to fill on the board.

4. Hagen Smith, LHP, Arkansas (Rogers)

5. JJ Wetherholt, 2B/SS, West Virginia (Passan)

6. Braden Montgomery, OF, Texas A&M (Schoenfield)

Rogers: It is easy. Smith is the perfect lefty within the first spherical, and that is simply not one thing you possibly can cross up. A number of evaluators evaluate him to Carlos Rodon when he got here out of faculty. That is ok for me, and the decide checks off a necessity for each group: left-handed pitching.

Passan: Wetherholt might go along with the primary total decide in the true draft. And even when he does not, his beautiful left-handed swing and talent to play shortstop makes him much more invaluable. If you wish to give me the 2 greatest hit instruments within the draft, I am very happy to take ’em.

Schoenfield: I like Wetherholt; I do not like his hamstrings, which have bothered him every of the previous two years (he missed two months in 2024). I am blissful to take Montgomery, a switch-hitting star with a 70 arm and 27 dwelling runs for Texas A&M. How’s that for a one-two energy punch?

McDaniel: Oof for Jesse. I even have Chase Burns over Smith by a good margin, so he did not make up for what he missed by not having one of many prime two picks. Wetherholt might be going to be my third-best prospect within the draft, so Passan continues a powerful begin.

7. Nick Kurtz, 1B, Wake Forest (Schoenfield)

8. Chase Burns, RHP, Wake Forest (Passan)

9. Konnor Griffin, SS, Jackson Prep (Flowood, Miss.) (Rogers)

Passan: Maintain on. So I received the perfect pitcher within the draft with my third selection? You guys are making this too simple.

Rogers: I received doubtlessly the perfect participant in your entire draft with my third decide? McDaniel will again me up on this (I feel). Griffin could possibly be a star.

Schoenfield: And I get the following Anthony Rizzo to hitch my super-duper power-hitting squad.

McDaniel: In a tricky place to select, David will get two of the perfect choices on the board in Montgomery and Kurtz however leaves the perfect pitcher within the draft on the board. Passan scoops him up and is on a heater to start out issues off. My comp for Griffin is Fernando Tatis Jr., so I am on board with Jesse’s decide having an enormous upside, however it might take some time and comes with extra threat in contrast with the faculty choices.

10. Christian Moore, 2B, Tennessee (Rogers)

11. Bryce Rainer, SS, Harvard-Westlake College (Los Angeles) (Passan)

12. Trey Yesavage, RHP, East Carolina (Schoenfield)

Passan: I would argue that I received the perfect highschool participant within the draft right here, Jesse. He is a giant, left-handed-hitting shortstop who has gotten Corey Seager comps. His hit device is much extra superior than Griffin’s, and he is received each bit the arm of Griffin, working fastballs frequently into the mid-90s from the mound.

Rogers: Notice to Jeff, not each participant popping out of Harvard-Westlake goes to be a star. Notice to Dave, good decide.

Schoenfield: I might have taken Moore, who hit 34 dwelling runs for the Vols, since I am all-in on energy hitters and exit velocity, however Yesavage is a elegant right-hander with plus management and a four-pitch arsenal that ought to enable him to advance rapidly to the majors.

McDaniel: There is a prime tier of 10 gamers in my thoughts (some scouts throw James Tibbs into that group and name it 11) and at decide 10, Jesse opts for arguably the perfect prospect within the subsequent tier in Moore. It is defensible, however in the event you have been anxious Griffin already crammed that spot, you possibly can transfer him out to middle subject. Passan retains it easy and takes the perfect participant out there once more. Sigh.

13. Seaver King, SS, Wake Forest (Schoenfield)

14. Cam Smith, 3B, Florida State (Passan)

15. James Tibbs, OF, Florida State (Rogers)

Schoenfield: Seaver King? Are you kidding me? I am not passing on a child with that title at 13 (he additionally has pace, high-end exit velocity and the flexibility to stay at shortstop or transfer to middle subject if wanted).

Passan: There is a participant whose expertise I choose barely to Smith’s, however third base past Smith and Condon — who’s most likely not going to be on the place by the point he reaches the massive leagues — is just too skinny to likelihood being caught with the next-best possibility.

Rogers: There’s little doubt — for my part — that Tibbs is the perfect participant on the board outdoors the highest 10, so to get him at 15 looks like a steal.

Passan: Tibbs was that participant, for the report. Good decide, Jesse.

McDaniel: The primary misplay by Passan! I’ve Tibbs ranked over his teammate Smith and that is now the extra consensus view, which flipped throughout the spring. Jesse makes up floor by scooping up the sturdy worth of Tibbs whereas David will get probably the most positionally versatile participant within the first spherical in King.

16. William Schmidt, RHP, Catholic HS (Baton Rouge, La.) (Rogers)

17. Ryan Waldschmidt, OF, Kentucky (Passan)

18. Brody Brecht, RHP, Iowa (Schoenfield)

Passan: Outfield is skinny on this draft, so I am lots blissful to get a toolshed who was the perfect participant on among the finest groups within the nation and carried out within the SEC.

Schoenfield: I handed on Chase Burns earlier, however am blissful to get Brecht right here. A large receiver on the Iowa soccer group, Brecht lastly targeted on pitching in 2024 and delivered a breakout season, sitting 96-97 and as much as 101 with motion. He wants to enhance his management, however I will wager on the athleticism to assist him in professional ball.

Passan: It is at all times nice when the very first thing you point out a few baseball participant is that he performed soccer.

Rogers: I noticed Brecht play in individual a number of instances — why is why I did not take him in both sport.

McDaniel: I just like the picks of Waldschmidt and Brecht, however I am the low man within the business on Schmidt. I fear a bit concerning the command and what usually being maxed out when it comes to stuff in highschool means for long-term projection. Proficient participant, however I would have taken Cam Caminiti over Schmidt among the many prime prep pitchers.

19. Carson Benge, OF, Oklahoma State (Schoenfield)

20. Vance Honeycutt, OF, North Carolina (Passan)

21. Tommy White, 3B, LSU (Rogers)

Passan: Benge is a superbly stable decide right here, however I am blissful to get Honeycutt, who at one level was thought-about the perfect participant within the class. After a disappointing sophomore season, he rebounded with a wonderful 2024 — and an excellent higher Faculty World Sequence. And whereas I’ve received Bazzana enjoying middle subject and Honeycutt in proper to make the most of his plus arm, I will gladly shift Honeycutt again to middle, the place he can actually catch the ball, if want be.

Schoenfield: I discover that Jeff conveniently did not point out that Honeycutt struck out 83 instances in 62 video games. In faculty. I simply do not see how that is going to translate to professional ball. Simply means an excessive amount of swing-and-miss.

Rogers: White is my midround sleeper decide. He may not have a place within the subject — at greatest he is a primary baseman — however his uncooked energy to all fields is plain. A shoulder damage slowed him final season, however I might simply put him in the identical class of hitter as Dave and Jeff’s third-sacker.

McDaniel: I love the Benge decide right here. I feel he is my decide to click on amongst this stretch of faculty bats. Some evaluators suppose his swing has a straightforward repair to unlock extra potential, whereas he is a plus runner who can play middle subject and is within the mid-90s on the mound. Honeycutt is an excellent polarizing participant on this class — my guess is he’ll be an All-Star or a complete bust — whereas Tommy White will get milquetoast critiques from scouts who I feel are wanting previous the issues he does properly.

22. Slade Caldwell, OF, Valley View HS (Jonesboro, Ark.) (Rogers)

23. Caleb Lomavita, C, Cal (Passan)

24. Theo Gillen, 2B/SS, Westlake HS (Austin, Texas) (Schoenfield)

Rogers: I will admit, I used to be scrambling on the Caldwell decide. However I really like his motor and I take a look at it this manner: If a 5-foot-9 18-year-old with out quite a lot of energy is getting this a lot consideration, he have to be doing one thing proper. He is a really mature hitter for his age — and moreover, I feel I received a greater catcher than Jeff with my final decide.

Passan: I might’ve gone with Lomavita, Walker Janek from Sam Houston State or Malcolm Moore from Stanford. I opted for Lomavita as a result of he is the perfect mixture of current manufacturing, sturdy competitors and instruments ceiling. And Dave — that is good worth on Gillen. This format can work out properly in the event you can float a man as a result of the place he performs is crammed on the opposite two groups. You may see what I imply with my last decide.

McDaniel: I am one other huge fan of the Gillen decide. He could also be second base-only attributable to his arm, however in hushed tones some actually sharp scouts are telling me he is the perfect hitter within the draft outdoors of the highest 10 picks. Lomavita could possibly be an All-Star if he cuts down the chase, so he gives a stable ground/ceiling proposition. I fear about Caldwell’s energy upside, however the child can hit.

25. Walker Janek, C, Sam Houston State (Schoenfield)

26. Billy Amick, 1B/3B, Tennessee (Passan)

27. Dakota Jordan, OF, Mississippi State (Rogers)

Schoenfield: Janek is the second catcher on this draft, however he is thought to be the perfect defensive catcher on this class — and hit .364 with 17 dwelling runs, with an almost even walk-to-strikeout ratio (40 to 45). Lomavita, who went to Jeff earlier, had 12 walks and 43 strikeouts. Once more, I’ve hassle seeing how that may translate to professional ball. I will take my man.

Rogers: I really like my decide right here. Jordan is a superb athlete who might need been downgraded whereas concentrating on soccer at Mississippi State. He has provided that up and could possibly be nearly as good as anybody taken close to him — making him an excellent worth decide for me late in our draft. Cannot say the identical about any of Dave’s late ones.

Schoenfield: Good roll of the cube there, Jesse. Plenty of instruments … oh, and plenty of strikeouts (84 in 63 video games), similar to Honeycutt. If you happen to guys try to construct the 2024 Mariners offense, you’ve got succeeded.

McDaniel: I feel the transfer is to attend till the opposite faculty catchers are picked and take the final one as a result of they’re all fairly related; appears like Jesse is taking my recommendation. Amick and Jordan each have some contact issues however 30-homer upside with stable SEC efficiency.

28. Malcolm Moore, C, Stanford (Rogers)

29. Cam Caminiti, LHP, Saguaro Excessive (Scottsdale, Ariz.) (Passan)

30. Kellon Lindsey, OF/SS, Hardee HS (Wauchula, Fla.) (Schoenfield)

Rogers: I feel I made one other worth decide as Moore holds up in opposition to the opposite two catchers taken within the draft. If the decide hits, I’ve an excellent, left-handed-hitting catcher. There’s further worth in that as properly.

Schoenfield: Let’s give Jeff credit score right here. He waited on his second pitcher and received the top-rated prep pitcher in Caminiti (former MVP Ken Caminiti’s nephew). Good choice. Lindsey is an absolute burner who might want to discover some energy and will profile at shortstop, however I would take his pace and transfer him to middle.

McDaniel: How did Caminiti fall this far? Solely six pitchers shall be drafted on this train, however I feel he is the third-best one. Jesse will get good worth in Moore whereas David shoots for the moon with a Trea Turner clone in Lindsey.

Why is your group the perfect?

Passan: I’ve received the perfect hitting and the perfect pitching. I suppose I can define why — Bazzana is a future All-Star, Wetherholt and Rainer prime abilities, the remainder of my hitters confirmed faculty bats and my pitching a fantastic mixture of current stuff and future potential — however the manufacturing alone tells a narrative upon which I needn’t expound any additional.

Rogers: All of it facilities round Griffin, who one evaluator stated was Mike Trout — if the decide pans out. That is perhaps excessive reward however you get the image. I received a top-end expertise at No. 9 after already getting the perfect left-hander within the draft in Smith and a masher in Caglianone. And who’s to say the latter participant will not be the following Ohtani, contemplating he threw 73 innings final 12 months whereas hitting 35 dwelling runs? And I like my highschool children. I am relying on McDaniel saying the identical.

Schoenfield: The opposite groups do not come near matching the center of my order with Condon, Kurtz, Montgomery and Benge hitting 2-3-4-5. All guys who mashed in faculty with out the swing-and-miss or chase points that Passan and Rogers can have from a few of their hitters. Throw in two highschool speedsters in Gillen and Lindsey and I really like this lineup. Sure, I will want Brecht to carry out, however I will make the comparability to Jeff Samardzija, a two-sport athlete at Notre Dame who excelled as a pitcher within the majors.

McDaniel’s last verdict

I attempted to cover it a bit within the round-by-round commentary, however this was a runaway win by Passan. I graded every slot in every lineup (greatest outfielder, second-best outfielder, and so forth. for OF and P slots) and he gained at each spot besides first base and third base. If you happen to’ll take a look at the primary spherical, the 2 spots he misplaced have been the opposite two prime picks; he primarily gained each different matchup after that. Jeff, possibly you’d wish to take my spot at respective sweat containers/stadiums across the South for the following two months scouting the perfect prospects for the 2025 MLB draft? You might need a future on this if that complete information breaker factor does not work out.